Indiana Tax Appeals: Your Rights and Process Explained

Every year, countless Indiana homeowners and business owners pay more taxes than they truly owe. According to data from the Indiana Department of Revenue, thousands of assessments are later reduced or overturned because of simple errors in property valuation or missed filing deadlines. Yet many taxpayers never appeal, assuming the process is too complicated or time-consuming.

Filing an appeal isn’t just a right under Indiana law—it’s often a smart financial move. Whether you’ve received a tax bill that doesn’t reflect your property’s actual tax value or believe a refund denial was issued in error, the state’s tax appeal system exists to help you challenge those decisions. Acting quickly can mean recovering hundreds of dollars or losing that refund entirely.

This guide walks you step-by-step through Indiana’s appeal process. You’ll learn to file an appeal with the correct agency, meet strict deadlines, gather persuasive evidence, and prepare for your hearing. We’ll also explain how Indiana’s Department of Revenue, local assessment boards, and the Tax Court each play a role in resolving disputes. Most importantly, you’ll understand how to avoid costly mistakes—like missing appeal deadlines or submitting incomplete forms—that can prevent your case from being heard.

Understanding Indiana Tax Appeals

A tax appeal is your formal opportunity to challenge a tax assessment, refund denial, or other decision made by the Indiana Department of Revenue or your county assessor’s office. Under Indiana law, taxpayers can question whether their property’s assessed value or tax liability accurately reflects reality. Appeals are not just for property owners—businesses and individuals may file if they believe their taxes were miscalculated or a refund was unfairly denied.

In simple terms, an appeal is how you ensure that your tax bill reflects the actual tax value of your property or income. It allows taxpayers to provide additional evidence, correct factual errors, and present their case for reconsideration before an administrative or judicial body.

Why Tax Appeals Matter

Tax appeals serve a vital purpose: they help preserve fairness in Indiana’s tax system. When assessments are inaccurate, taxpayers may pay more than their share, while errors left uncorrected can also affect future assessment years. Filing an appeal allows you to protect your financial interests and ensure compliance with Indiana tax law.

Beyond fairness, the financial impact can be significant. A single appeal may result in hundreds or even thousands of dollars in savings, depending on the size of the overassessment. More importantly, filing a timely appeal preserves your legal rights to further review if the issue escalates to the Indiana Board of Tax Review or Indiana Tax Court.

How Indiana Differs from Federal Appeals

Unlike federal tax disputes handled through the IRS and U.S. Tax Court, Indiana tax appeals operate under a unique structure. State-level appeals are guided by Indiana’s own administrative procedures, forms, and strict deadlines. For example, Indiana’s Department of Revenue allows just 60 days to file a written protest, whereas federal processes often extend longer.

Later in this guide, you’ll find a comparison table detailing how Indiana’s system differs from federal tax appeals in structure, deadlines, and filing procedures. For now, remember that Indiana’s process is particular—understanding who to contact, when to file, and what forms to submit is essential to success.

Agencies Involved in Indiana Tax Appeals

Understanding which government agency handles your appeal is crucial. Indiana’s system involves several departments and boards, each responsible for specific types of taxes and appeal stages. Knowing where your case belongs can save valuable time and prevent costly delays.

Indiana Department of Revenue (DOR)

The Indiana Department of Revenue manages appeals for most state-level taxes, including income, sales, and use taxes. When you receive a proposed assessment or refund denial, the DOR allows you to file a written protest. Taxpayers can submit the Protest Submission Form (State Form 56317) and request a hearing or written review through the department’s Legal Division.

Appeals can be mailed to the DOR or filed electronically through the Indiana Taxpayer Information Management Engine (INTIME). Choosing the electronic option often speeds up processing and allows you to upload supporting documents directly. The DOR’s Legal Division will then review your evidence and issue a final determination, which can later be appealed to the Indiana Tax Court if necessary.

Indiana Board of Tax Review (IBTR)

The Indiana Board of Tax Review handles property tax assessment appeals beyond the county level. This independent state board reviews disputes involving assessed value, exemptions, and deductions. After your county’s Property Tax Assessment Board of Appeals (PTABOA) decides, you can file Form 131—Petition for Review of Assessment—with the IBTR within 45 days.

The IBTR process is more formal than county-level reviews. Hearings may include witness testimony, property evidence, and legal arguments presented by both sides. Once the IBTR issues its written decision, it can be appealed to the Indiana Tax Court for judicial review if the taxpayer disagrees with the outcome.

Local Property Tax Assessment Boards of Appeals (PTABOA)

Every Indiana county has its own PTABOA, which acts as the first level of review for property assessment appeals. Homeowners and property owners must begin by filing Form 130—Taxpayer’s Notice to Initiate an Appeal—with their local assessor’s office. The PTABOA reviews your claim, holds a hearing, and issues a written determination.

If you disagree with the board’s decision, you can escalate the case to the IBTR. For many property owners, this is where they first see results, as PTABOA decisions often involve reassessing the actual tax value of the property.

Indiana Tax Court

The Indiana Tax Court is the top appeals court, with exclusive jurisdiction over state tax disputes. The court hears cases appealed from either the DOR or the IBTR and issues final judicial rulings based on Indiana law. Hearings are formal, and legal representation is strongly recommended.

The Indiana Tax Court’s decisions are binding and establish precedent for future appeals. This court represents the last step for taxpayers seeking final resolution or clarification of complex issues.

Types of Tax Appeals

The Indiana tax appeals process isn’t one-size-fits-all. The type of appeal you file depends on what kind of tax decision you’re challenging—state income tax, business tax, or property tax assessments. Understanding the distinctions ensures you follow the correct procedure and preserve your right to review further.

Administrative Review (State-Level Appeals)

The Indiana Department of Revenue (DOR) handles administrative reviews. This process applies to most non-property taxes, including income, sales, use, and business taxes. When the DOR issues a proposed assessment or refund denial, taxpayers can submit a written protest within 60 days.

You may request either a written review or an informal hearing. During this stage, a DOR hearing officer evaluates your protest, supporting evidence, and legal reasoning. Once the department issues its final determination, you can appeal to the Indiana Tax Court if you disagree with the outcome. Because of Indiana’s strict 60-day protest deadline, timely filing is critical to keeping your case active.

Property Tax Appeals

Property tax appeals follow a multi-step process that begins locally and may progress to state review. These appeals address issues such as an inflated assessed value, denial of an exemption, or an incorrect property classification.

Stages of the property appeal process include:

• Local Assessment Review: You must start filing Form 130 with your county assessor’s office. This allows you to challenge the assessment’s accuracy or identify factual errors in your property record.
  
  
• County PTABOA Review: If the assessor denies your claim, the Property Tax Assessment Board of Appeals (PTABOA) reviews your case. The PTABOA can hold hearings, request additional information, and issue written findings.
  
  
• State IBTR Review: If the PTABOA denies your appeal or fails to act within 180 days, you can file Form 131 with the Indiana Board of Tax Review (IBTR) within 45 days. The IBTR examines your evidence and may hold a formal hearing before deciding.

Direct Appeals and Special Situations

Some property owners can skip the county review process under certain conditions. For instance, if the taxpayer and the local assessor agree, you can file a direct appeal with the IBTR. Additionally, if the PTABOA does not issue a decision within 180 days, Indiana law automatically grants you the right to appeal to the state level.

Direct appeals help taxpayers avoid unnecessary delays and ensure their cases progress toward resolution. However, it’s essential to document every step and maintain copies of all submissions to protect your rights.

How to File a Tax Appeal in Indiana

Filing an Indiana tax appeal may seem complex initially, but the process becomes manageable when broken into clear steps. Whether you’re appealing a Department of Revenue decision or a property tax assessment, the key to success is acting quickly, completing every required form, and providing thorough evidence.

Step-by-Step Process for DOR Appeals

1. Review Your Notice Carefully: When you receive a proposed assessment or refund denial from the Indiana Department of Revenue (DOR), review the notice in detail. Ensure you understand the disputed issue—such as an adjustment, refund denial, or penalty assessment.
   
   
2. File a Written Protest: You must submit your protest within 60 days of the notice date. Use the Protest Submission Form (State Form 56317) and include a clear explanation of why you disagree with the DOR’s decision. Protests filed after this deadline are automatically dismissed, so act promptly.
   
   
3. Choose Your Filing Method: Mail your protest to the DOR’s Legal Division or file electronically through the Indiana Taxpayer Information Management Engine (INTIME). Filing online allows you to upload evidence, track your case, and receive faster submission confirmation.
   
   
4. Attach Supporting Evidence: Include all documents that strengthen your case, such as tax returns, receipts, legal citations, or correspondence with the department. Well-organized evidence demonstrates credibility and increases your chance of success.
   
   
5. Request a Hearing or Written Decision: You may request an informal hearing before a DOR hearing officer or ask for a written decision based on your submitted materials. Depending on availability, hearings can be held in person, by phone, or via video conference.

Filing Property Tax Appeals

Appealing property tax assessments follows a structured path from the local to the state.

• Start Locally with Form 130: File this form with your county assessor’s office to dispute your property’s assessed value. You can challenge subjective issues (like overvaluation) and objective errors (like incorrect lot size or property classification).
  
  
• Escalate to the PTABOA if Necessary: If your local appeal is denied, it automatically moves to your county’s Property Tax Assessment Board of Appeals (PTABOA). The board may schedule a hearing to review your evidence and issue a written decision.
  
  
• File Form 131 with the IBTR: If you disagree with the PTABOA’s determination, you have 45 days to file Form 131 with the Indiana Board of Tax Review (IBTR). The IBTR will review your petition, schedule a hearing, and issue a written ruling.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

• Missing Deadlines: Indiana’s deadlines are strict. A single missed date can void your entire appeal. Mark every submission deadline on your calendar and confirm receipt of all documents.
  
  
• Incomplete Forms: Unsigned or partially filled forms are automatically rejected. Before submitting, double-check that every section, date, and signature line is complete.
  
  
• Weak Documentation: Simply stating your disagreement isn’t enough. Provide evidence such as comparable property sales, prior assessment records, or proof of clerical errors.
  
  
• Failing to Keep Copies: Always retain a complete copy of every document you send. This ensures you have proof if questions arise during the appeal review.

Now that your appeal has been properly filed, the next essential step is tracking key deadlines and understanding which forms apply to each process stage.

Key Deadlines and Forms

Indiana’s tax appeal system is highly time-sensitive. Missing a filing date or using the wrong form can result in your case being dismissed before it’s reviewed. Understanding the correct timelines and documentation is essential to protect your right to appeal.

Important Timeframes

Every stage of the Indiana tax appeals process has its filing deadline. The table below outlines your key time limits when submitting your forms or requesting reviews.

Key Indiana Tax Appeal Deadlines

1. DOR Administrative Appeal

• Action Required: File a written protest using State Form 56317.
• Deadline: Within 60 days from the notice date.
• Extension Available? No.

2. Request for Rehearing (DOR)

• Action Required: Submit a written rehearing request.
• Deadline: Within 30 days from the final determination.
• Extension Available? No.

3. Appeal to the Indiana Tax Court

• Action Required: File a court petition after receiving a final decision from the DOR or the Indiana Board of Tax Review (IBTR).
• Deadline: Within 90 days, extendable to 180 days upon request.
• Extension Available? Yes.

4. Property Tax Appeal (Form 130)

• Action Required: File an initial appeal with the county assessor.
• Deadline: Applies to the current assessment year only.
• Extension Available? Not applicable.

5. IBTR Appeal (Form 131)

• Action Required: File after the PTABOA (Property Tax Assessment Board of Appeals) denial.
• Deadline: Within 45 days of the decision date.
• Extension Available? No.

6. IBTR Direct Appeal

• Action Required: File when the PTABOA fails to act.
• Deadline: After 180 days of inactivity.
• Extension Available? Automatic right to appeal applies.

Failing to meet these deadlines can cause your case to be dismissed automatically, even if your claim is valid. To protect your appeal rights, always verify the mailing date on your notice and calculate your filing window carefully. Keeping a written record of each deadline helps ensure no step is missed.

Required Forms

Each form used in the Indiana tax appeals process serves a distinct purpose. Using the correct one ensures your appeal reaches the proper agency and is processed without delay.

• State Form 56317: This form is used to protest a Department of Revenue (DOR) assessment or refund denial. It must include a written explanation of your disagreement and supporting documentation.
  
  
• Form 130 – Taxpayer’s Notice to Initiate an Appeal: This form begins your property tax assessment appeal at the county level. It can address valuation disputes or factual errors in the assessor’s property records.
  
  
• Form 131 – Petition for Review of Assessment: This form allows you to escalate your case to the Indiana Board of Tax Review (IBTR) after receiving a PTABOA decision. It must be filed within 45 days of that decision to remain valid.
  
  
• Form 17-T – Claim for Refund: This form requests a refund after a successful appeal or correction to your property’s assessed value. Always include copies of the final determination or relevant correspondence to support your refund claim.
  
  
• Power of Attorney (Form POA-1): This form authorizes another person—such as a CPA, tax consultant, or attorney—to represent you during your appeal. You must sign and date this document before it is considered valid.

How to Submit Forms

Taxpayers can file their appeals in several ways, depending on the agency. Department of Revenue forms can be submitted through the INTIME portal, allowing faster processing and electronic confirmation. Property tax forms for the Indiana Board of Tax Review are filed through the POPLAR system, while county-level appeals may still require paper submissions to your local assessor’s office.

Always keep a timestamped or signed copy of every form you send. Proof of submission protects you if a form is misplaced or if there’s a question about whether it was received on time.

Preparing for Your Appeal

Filing your appeal is only the beginning. The strength of your documentation, organization, and presentation will often determine whether your case succeeds. Careful preparation improves credibility and shows you understand your rights and responsibilities under Indiana law.

Collecting Strong Evidence

Evidence is the backbone of every successful Indiana tax appeal. You must demonstrate that the original assessment or determination was incorrect and support your argument with clear documentation.

• For Department of Revenue (DOR) Appeals: Gather your original tax returns, payment records, receipts, and any correspondence with the DOR. Include explanations for discrepancies, such as corrected figures or missing documentation that may have led to the dispute. If you’re challenging a penalty or adjustment, cite relevant Indiana Code provisions or tax bulletins that support your position.
  
  
• For Property Tax Appeals: Collect recent property appraisals, comparable sales data, and photographs showing the current condition of your property. Include repair estimates, inspection reports, or evidence proving the property’s tax value is lower than assessed. More specific and factual data lead to a stronger case.

Understanding the Burden of Proof

In every Indiana tax appeal, the taxpayer carries the burden of proof. This means you must show, with credible evidence, that the assessment or decision was incorrect. Presenting organized documentation—such as appraisal comparisons, cost analyses, or financial statements—helps convince the hearing officer or board that your position is accurate and reasonable.

Considering Professional Help

While individuals may represent themselves, professional guidance can make a meaningful difference in complex or high-value cases. Tax attorneys, CPAs, and licensed property consultants understand procedural rules and persuasive strategies for presenting evidence. Investing in expert help may prevent costly mistakes and increase your likelihood of a favorable outcome.

What to Expect During Hearings

Once your appeal is filed and your evidence is ready, the next stage is the hearing. This is your opportunity to present your case and demonstrate why the original assessment or decision should be changed. Understanding the process beforehand can help reduce stress and improve your performance.

Department of Revenue (DOR) Hearings

Hearings conducted by the Indiana Department of Revenue are informal but structured. A neutral hearing officer—an attorney employed by the department—reviews your protest, listens to your explanation, and considers the supporting evidence you provide. Sessions usually last about an hour and can take place in person, by phone, or via video conference. You should arrive prepared to summarize your case clearly and answer follow-up questions about your documentation or calculations.

Indiana Board of Tax Review (IBTR) Hearings

Hearings before the Indiana Board of Tax Review are more formal and follow specific administrative procedures. You may call witnesses, submit exhibits, and present detailed arguments regarding your property’s assessed value or tax status. The IBTR panel records testimony, evaluates all submitted evidence, and later issues a written decision that explains its reasoning. If you disagree with the outcome, this decision can be appealed to the Indiana Tax Court.

Settlement Opportunities

Indiana encourages resolution without prolonged litigation. At nearly any stage, taxpayers may propose settlement discussions to resolve disputes more efficiently. However, settlements must be initiated by the taxpayer, and approval depends on whether the proposed resolution aligns with state tax standards.

Comparison: Indiana vs. Federal Tax Appeals

Taxpayers often assume that appealing a state tax issue works like a federal IRS appeal, but the two systems differ significantly. Indiana’s process operates under its laws, deadlines, and administrative bodies. Understanding these differences will help you avoid missteps that could delay or weaken your case.

Comparison: Indiana vs. Federal Tax Appeals

1. Governing Authority

• Indiana Tax Appeals: Managed by the Indiana Department of Revenue (DOR), Indiana Board of Tax Review (IBTR), and the Indiana Tax Court.
• Federal Tax Appeals (IRS): Handled by the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) and the U.S. Tax Court.

2. Primary Focus

• Indiana: Addresses state-level taxes, including property, income, and sales tax.
• Federal: Focuses on federal income and payroll taxes.

3. Appeal Deadlines

• Indiana: Strict deadlines — 60 days for DOR protests and 45 days for IBTR appeals.
• Federal: Typically 90 days to respond to IRS notices.

4. Filing Forms

• Indiana: Uses state-specific forms, such as Form 56317, Form 130, and Form 131.
• Federal: Uses federal forms, including Form 12203 and Form 656, among others.

5. Hearing Structure

• Indiana: Involves informal DOR hearings and administrative reviews before reaching the IBTR or court stage.
• Federal: Conducted as administrative appeals within the IRS before judicial review.

6. Judicial Review

• Indiana: The Indiana Tax Court has exclusive jurisdiction over state tax disputes.
• Federal: Judicial review occurs through the U.S. Tax Court or federal district courts.

7. Settlement Process

• Indiana: Settlements must be initiated by the taxpayer and are guided by state statutes.
• Federal: The IRS may offer settlement programs or mediation as part of the appeals process.

These distinctions show that Indiana’s system emphasizes strict procedural compliance and taxpayer responsibility for initiating appeals. While both systems aim to ensure fairness, the state’s version moves faster and demands earlier action.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

How long do I have to file an Indiana tax appeal?

After receiving a notice or refund denial, you generally have 60 days to file a written protest with the Department of Revenue. Property tax appeals follow a different schedule—you must file Form 130 for the current assessment year and submit Form 131 within 45 days of a PTABOA decision. Missing these deadlines can forfeit your right to review under Indiana law.

Can I file my appeal electronically?

Yes, the Department of Revenue allows taxpayers to file protests through the INTIME system, which provides faster processing and immediate confirmation. Property tax assessment appeals can also be filed online through the POPLAR portal, managed by the Indiana Board of Tax Review. Electronic filing ensures your documents are received on time and helps preserve your right to review further if needed.

Do I need to pay my taxes while my appeal is pending?

For Department of Revenue appeals, tax collection is generally paused during the review process. However, property owners must often pay their property tax bills to avoid penalties and interest. Some counties may permit you to post a bond instead of payment. Always contact your county auditor or assessor’s office before withholding any payment.

Can I represent myself in an Indiana tax appeal?

Yes, you may represent yourself throughout the appeals process, from local hearings to the Indiana Tax Court. However, complex cases—especially those involving multiple assessment years or high-value properties—often benefit from professional representation. Hiring a CPA or tax attorney ensures accurate filings, strong documentation, and adherence to all state rules and procedures during your appeal.

What happens if I win my appeal?

If your appeal is successful, your property’s assessed value or tax liability will be corrected based on actual tax value, and you may qualify for a refund. Refunds are typically processed through Form 17-T and filed with your county auditor. Depending on the decision date and tax year, payments may be received or credited within several weeks after your appeal is finalized.

‍