New York Unfiled Payroll Tax Returns Checklist.
Introduction
Unfiled payroll tax returns occur when a business has not submitted required wage and withholding reports to New York State. This issue is significant because payroll taxes directly affect employees’ tax records, state revenue, and the business’s compliance standing.
When payroll returns remain unfiled, New York’s Department of Taxation and Finance begins collection actions that can result in penalties, interest charges, and potential enforcement activity. Understanding what unfiled payroll returns mean and what steps to take helps prevent the situation from becoming more serious and creates a clear path toward resolving the issue.
What This Issue Means
An unfiled payroll tax return is a wage and withholding report that was due to New York State but was not submitted by the required deadline. These returns report New York State withholding taxes, wage information, and unemployment insurance data to the state. When a return is identified as unfiled, New York’s tax department has recognized a gap in the business’s filing record and has taken steps to document this non-compliance.
Why the State Issued This or Requires This
New York requires payroll tax returns to track wages paid, taxes withheld from employees, and employer contributions. These filings help the state verify that employee tax records are accurate and that businesses are meeting their legal obligations.
When returns go unfiled, the state cannot verify this information and typically issues notices or begins collection activity to prompt filing. The state’s requirement stems from employment law and tax code provisions that mandate regular reporting of payroll data.
What Happens If This Is Ignored
If unfiled payroll tax returns are not addressed, New York typically escalates collection actions through additional notices, penalty assessments, and, if necessary, wage garnishment or asset seizure procedures. Interest accrues on unpaid tax amounts, and penalties increase over time.
In some cases, the state may pursue administrative or legal enforcement against the business owner or responsible party.
What This Does NOT Mean
An unfiled payroll tax return notice does not automatically mean criminal charges have been filed or that the business is under criminal investigation. It also does not mean the business cannot file returns going forward or that past errors cannot be corrected. The notice represents a filing and payment gap—not a judgment of intent or a final enforcement action.
Checklist: What to Do After Identifying Unfiled Payroll Tax
Returns
Step 1: Gather Documentation
Locate all notices or correspondence from New York’s Department of Taxation and Finance related to unfiled returns. Identify the specific tax periods that are unfiled, typically by quarters.
Collect payroll records, employee wage information, and withholding amounts for those periods.
Review bank statements or accounting records to confirm what was paid and what was withheld. Determine whether the business filed federal payroll returns for the same periods, as this information is relevant.
Step 2: Contact the New York Department of Taxation and Finance
Call the Withholding Tax Information Center at 518-485-6654 for business withholding tax questions. Provide the business name, employer identification number, and the tax periods in question.
Ask the representative to confirm which specific periods are unfiled and which forms are needed, and request information about any penalties or interest that have accrued. Ask whether there are any current collection actions in place or if additional notices will be issued. Note the representative’s name, the date of the call, and any reference number provided.
Step 3: Calculate or Reconstruct Payroll Data
If payroll records are available, compile wage and withholding information for each unfiled period. If documents are incomplete or unavailable, contact a bookkeeper, accountant, or payroll service to help reconstruct the data.
Verify that the reconstructed or compiled data matches federal payroll filings if those were filed.
Document the source of the information, such as payroll software, bank records, or employee statements. Set aside funds or make a plan to cover any unpaid taxes and penalties identified during this process.
Step 4: Prepare the Unfiled Returns
Obtain the correct New York payroll tax forms for the periods in question. The required form is
NYS-45, Quarterly Combined Withholding, Wage Reporting, and Unemployment Insurance
Return. Follow the instructions on the form to enter wage and withholding information for each employee. Double-check all figures for accuracy before submission.
If preparing returns for multiple periods, ensure each form covers the correct quarter and year.
Consider having an accountant or tax professional review the returns before filing to confirm accuracy.
Step 5: Submit the Returns
File returns electronically if the business is registered for online filing with the Department of
Taxation and Finance or by mail to the address listed on the form. Include a cover letter explaining that these are delinquent returns and reference any correspondence from the state.
Keep a copy of each return filed, along with the mailing receipt or electronic filing confirmation. If filing by mail, use certified mail with a return receipt to document submission. Allow ten to fifteen business days for receipt of mailed returns.
Step 6: Address Any Outstanding Tax Balance
Review the returns to calculate the total tax liability, which is the amount of tax owed. Determine whether any payment was previously made toward these periods. Contact the Department of
Taxation and Finance to confirm the exact balance owed, including any penalties or interest. If the balance cannot be paid in full immediately, ask about payment plan options or other resolution procedures. Keep documentation of any payments made and the dates they were submitted.
Step 7: Monitor for Follow-Up Correspondence
Watch for acknowledgment that the returns were received and processed. Expect correspondence confirming whether the returns are now in compliance or require additional action. If a balance remains due, the state will typically issue a demand notice or bill. Keep all notices and correspondence in a file for reference. Note any deadlines mentioned in follow-up notices and respond by those dates.
- Missing the deadline in follow-up notices can result in additional enforcement action if
- Rejecting returns due to incomplete or inaccurate information can delay the resolution
- Assuming the issue is resolved without written confirmation is a mistake—wait for official
- Not keeping copies of filed returns creates problems if questions arise about compliance
- Filing only some of the unfiled periods leaves compliance gaps when multiple quarters or
- Failing to pay any balance owed after filing leaves the debt unresolved, as filing returns
- State enforcement notices and responses
- Sales tax audits, assessments, and collections
- Payroll & trust fund tax enforcement issues
- Penalty and interest reduction options
- Payment plans and state tax relief eligibility
- Representation before state tax agencies
Step 8: Prevent Future Unfiled Returns
Establish a system to ensure future returns are filed on time, such as calendar reminders, accounting software alerts, or professional service agreements. Confirm the due dates for all required payroll tax returns, which are typically quarterly for New York. If using a payroll service or accountant, verify that they have explicit instructions to file returns with New York State. Set
aside funds each pay period to cover payroll tax liability. File returns even if payment cannot be made in full—filing on time is separate from paying on time.
What Happens After This Is Completed
Once returns are filed, the Department of Taxation and Finance will process them and verify the information submitted. The state will send a confirmation of receipt and a determination of whether the returns are now in compliance.
If a tax balance exists, a bill or demand notice will be issued with instructions for payment.
Processing typically takes ten to thirty days, though this timeframe is not guaranteed and may vary depending on state workload.
Common Mistakes to Avoid the state issues a response notice with a deadline. process. Returns with missing employee names, incorrect wage amounts, or math errors require resubmission. acknowledgment from the Department of Taxation and Finance. later. years are unfiled. and paying the tax owed are separate obligations.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does the Department of Taxation and Finance take to process unfiled returns?
The state does not publish a specific processing timeframe. Often, returns are processed within ten to 30 days, but this varies. Tracking the receipt through certified mail or electronic confirmation helps confirm submission.
Can I file multiple years of unfiled returns at the same time?
Yes, returns can be filed for multiple periods in one submission. Each return form covers one quarter, so various forms would be submitted if multiple periods are unfiled.
What if I no longer have payroll records for the unfiled periods?
An accountant or payroll professional can help reconstruct records using federal filings, bank statements, or other documentation. Contact the Department of Taxation and Finance to ask about acceptable documentation methods.
Do I have to pay penalties and interest in addition to the tax owed?
New York assesses penalties and interest on unfiled and unpaid payroll taxes according to state law. The specific amounts depend on how long the returns were unfiled and whether there were prior compliance issues. Contact the state to learn what amounts apply to the particular situation.
Can the business file future returns while addressing past unfiled returns?
Yes, filing current returns on time is separate from resolving past unfiled returns. Both should be done.
What if the business has closed or is no longer operating?
Even if a business has closed, unfiled and unpaid payroll taxes remain a liability. Contact the
Department of Taxation and Finance to discuss the options available for a closed business.
How do I know if there are other unfiled returns I don’t know about?
Contact the Department of Taxation and Finance directly and request a complete compliance history or a record of unfiled returns. The state can provide this information.
Can I get penalties reduced or removed?
New York has penalty relief provisions in certain circumstances. The Department of Taxation and Finance evaluates requests based on the specific facts. Information about penalty relief procedures is available through the state’s official website or by contacting the department directly.
Closing
Resolving unfiled payroll tax returns begins with identifying what has not been filed, submitting each late filing, and addressing any resulting tax debt. Completing each income tax return and confirming that every filed tax return is recorded correctly helps clarify your total tax obligation, including any interest and penalties.
Once the balance is known, you can determine the appropriate tax payment approach and understand how late filing may affect future tax refunds. If questions arise or the situation involves multiple years or complex issues, contacting the New York Department of Taxation and
Finance or consulting a qualified tax attorney can help ensure the matter is handled correctly and resolved.
Facing State Tax Enforcement Action?
If you’ve received a notice related to sales tax or payroll tax enforcement and aren’t sure how to respond, our team can help you understand your options and next steps.
We help with:
20+ years experience • Same-day reviews available
