Indiana Payroll Tax Nonpayment Emergency Checklist
Introduction
Indiana payroll tax nonpayment occurs when a business fails to deposit withheld state and county income taxes to the Indiana Department of Revenue. Because the money is deducted from employee wages, it is treated as a trust-type employee withholding under the Indiana
Code.
When deposits are missed, the Department of Revenue treats the case as a priority collection issue involving unpaid taxes and tax liability. This checklist explains what nonpayment of payroll taxes means and how to respond without creating additional Failure to File or failure-to-pay problems.
What This Issue Means
Indiana payroll tax nonpayment means withheld income taxes were not remitted by the deadline, even though they were deducted through payroll processing and reported on Form
WH-1. This differs from Corporate Income Tax, Fiduciary Tax, and Utility Receipt Tax because withholding taxes are tied to employee wages, not the business’s income tax return.
Once withholding taxes are deducted, Indiana law treats the funds as belonging to the state, not the business. As a result, the Indiana Department of Revenue may issue a Departmental
Notice, assess tax penalties, apply interest charges, and initiate collection activity involving bank accounts.
Why The State Issued This Or Requires This
Indiana requires employers, staffing companies, and payroll providers to deposit withheld income tax based on average monthly withholding, with tax returns filed through INTIME or approved systems. Missing an annual, monthly, or early monthly deadline can trigger Late
Payment exposure and Late Tax Payment Penalties.
The state issues notices because withheld taxes are not treated like estimated tax or an underpayment of estimated tax. Even if payroll software, payroll specialists, ASAP Payroll, staffing companies, or The Payroll Department caused a Faulty payment, the employer remains responsible for payroll tax payments, W-2 forms reporting, and tax compliance.
What Happens If This Is Ignored
If the business does not respond, the Indiana Department of Revenue may issue tax warrants, liens, levies, and enforce collection against bank accounts. Nonpayment increases unpaid tax liability through interest accrual, added tax penalties, and additional Departmental Notice correspondence referencing Failure to File and failure-to-pay penalty exposure.
Indiana law may also impose personal liability on responsible individuals with authority over payroll tax remittances and tax compliance, including officers and check signers. Delays increase financial risk and can make enforcement more disruptive to operations.
What This Does Not Mean
A payroll tax nonpayment notice does not automatically mean assets have been seized, permits have been revoked, or operations have been shut down, and it is not a final court judgment. In many cases, the state is still in a notice-and-response phase where documentation, corrected tax filings, or confirmed deposits can stabilize the account.
It also does not mean the issue involves unemployment insurance tax, which is handled separately by the Indiana Department of Workforce Development. Unemployment insurance tax follows different procedures from withholding taxes, even when a business also deals with employment tax returns or federal income tax obligations.
Checklist: What To Do After Receiving This Or Identifying
This Issue
Step 1: Locate The Departmental Notice And Identify The Tax Period
Gather all correspondence related to unpaid taxes, payroll taxes, or withholding taxes, and record the tax period, amount due, and response deadline. Keep notice dates together to track escalation and avoid missed response windows.
Step 2: Confirm Whether The Return Was Filed And The Deposit Was Sent
Review INTIME submissions, payroll withholding reports, and proof of direct deposit, ACH, or check payments. If payroll providers or payroll software were used, request transaction logs and filing confirmations tied to each WH-1 period.
Step 3: Reconcile Payroll Records Against State Claims
Match employee wages, employee withholdings, and payroll tax remittance totals to the state’s balance. Compare W-2 form totals and monthly payroll tax payments to identify gaps caused by payroll processing errors or faulty payments.
Step 4: Request An Official Account Statement
Contact the Indiana Department of Revenue and request a detailed statement showing deposits received, posting dates, and tax liability calculations. Ask for the balance as of a specific date to align interest rate and penalty figures.
Step 5: Separate Withholding Taxes From Other Tax Types
Confirm the notice applies to withholding taxes rather than sales tax rates, Personal income tax,
Individual adjusted gross income tax, or county taxes such as County income tax rates. Keep the County innkeeper's tax and food and beverage rates files separate to avoid misapplied payments.
Step 6: Contact The Correct Agency For Related Payroll Issues
Use the Indiana Department of Revenue for Form WH-1 and withholding taxes, and the Indiana
Department of Workforce Development for unemployment insurance tax matters. Sending documents to the wrong agency delays resolution.
Step 7: File Any Missing WH-1 Returns Immediately
If a Failure to file a state tax return exists for any WH-1 period, file it even if payment cannot be made in full. Filing prevents compounding exposure when Failure to File and Failure to Pay occur together.
Step 8: Ask About Payment Arrangements And Compliance Requirements
Ask the Department of Revenue about available options for resolving unpaid tax liability, including installment arrangements. Clarify ongoing payroll tax remittance requirements and obtain all terms in writing.
Step 9: Document Responsible-Person Roles And Controls
Document who controls payroll processing, approves payroll tax payments, and acts as a check signer. This record is essential if responsibility is reviewed due to payroll provider involvement.
Step 10: Verify Every Future Deposit And Retain Proof
Save INTIME confirmations, bank records, and payroll reports after each deposit. Keep proof tied to the Employer Identification Number and the correct tax period.
Step 11: Monitor For Escalation Notices Or Enforcement
Watch for notices referencing liens, levies, bank accounts, or heightened tax regulations, and respond promptly. Treat fraudulent return language as a separate high-priority issue.
- State enforcement notices and responses
- Sales tax audits, assessments, and collections
- Payroll & trust fund tax enforcement issues
- Penalty and interest reduction options
- Payment plans and state tax relief eligibility
- Representation before state tax agencies
Step 12: Maintain Ongoing Compliance Until Resolved
Continue filing WH-1 returns and making current deposits while resolving prior balances. Treat payroll tax obligations as non-negotiable duties tied to employee wages.
What Happens After This Is Completed
After documentation is reviewed, the Indiana Department of Revenue typically confirms posted payments and issues follow-up correspondence explaining the updated balance or next steps. If the debt remains unresolved, the state may proceed with liens, levies, or other collection actions based on prior notices.
Processing timelines vary depending on complexity, multiple tax periods, or corrected filings.
Keeping records aligned with state account statements reduces delays and administrative back-and-forth.
Common Mistakes To Avoid
Many businesses focus only on past-due balances and accidentally create new payroll taxes exposure by missing current WH-1 filings or deposits, compounding Failure to File and Failure to Pay issues. Others rely on payroll provider assurances without verifying INTIME confirmation, allowing a Faulty payment to go unnoticed until enforcement reaches bank accounts.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does A Payroll Tax Nonpayment Notice Mean My Business License Is
Suspended?
A notice alone does not suspend a license, but continued unpaid taxes can lead to escalating enforcement actions.
Can I Make A Partial Payment To Stop Enforcement?
Partial payments may be accepted, but they do not guarantee that enforcement will stop.
Confirm how payments will be applied.
How Do I Know If The Amount Owed Is Correct?
Request an official account statement and compare it to payroll records and payment proof.
Can The State Hold Me Personally Responsible?
Indiana Code allows personal liability for responsible persons involved in payroll tax remittance.
What if I cannot Pay The Full Amount Right Now?
Contact the Indiana Department of Revenue to discuss installment arrangements and compliance requirements.
Is Unemployment Insurance Tax Part Of This Notice?
No, withholding taxes are paid to the Indiana Department of Revenue, while unemployment insurance taxes are paid to the Indiana Department of Workforce Development.
Closing
Indiana payroll tax nonpayment is a high-risk issue because it involves withholding income taxes from employee wages and holding them in trust under Indiana Code. The safest approach is to verify the debt, correct missing tax returns, document deposits through INTIME, and remain current on future payroll tax payments while working with the Indiana Department of Revenue toward resolution.
Facing State Enforcement Action?
If you’ve received a notice related to sales tax or payroll tax enforcement, and aren’t sure how to respond, our team can help you understand your options and next steps.
We help with:
20+ years experience • Same-day reviews available
