IRS Form 1040 Schedule J (2019): Farmers & Fishermen Income

What IRS Form 1040 Schedule J (2019) Is For

IRS Form 1040 Schedule J (2019) allows farmers and fishermen to use income averaging, which calculates their income tax more evenly across multiple years rather than just in the current tax year. This helps reduce tax liability because taxable income is spread across several base years, rather than being taxed in a single high-income year. The Internal Revenue Service created this method to give farming and fishing businesses relief from fluctuations that commonly affect their operations, including weather, production cycles, and market conditions.

For step-by-step instructions on many IRS forms, visit our IRS Form Help Center.

When You’d Use IRS Form 1040 Schedule J (2019)

This section explains the situations in which Schedule J becomes beneficial for a taxpayer.

1. Large swings in eligible farm or fishing income: This applies when your income varies significantly from year to year because income averaging can reduce the impact of a sudden increase in taxable income.
   
   
2. Tax planning for volatile agricultural or aquaculture operations: This applies when crop and livestock sales fluctuate due to weather conditions or market volatility, because these changes may place you in a higher tax bracket without income averaging.
   
   
3. Needing to adjust previously filed tax returns: This applies if you plan to file an amended income tax return using Form 1040-X because Schedule J can still be attached if the correction window has not expired.
   
   
4. Changes in business structure or multiple income sources: This applies when income is reported on Schedule F, Schedule C, Schedule E, or Form 4835, because all revenue from the trade or business of farming or fishing must be combined for averaging purposes.

If you have unfiled federal returns, resolve these first—Schedule J calculations depend on accurate prior-year data.

Key Rules or Details for the 2019 Tax Year

This section outlines the core IRS requirements you must follow before using income averaging.

1. Only income from a qualifying farming or fishing business can be averaged: This rule applies because the Internal Revenue Service requires that the elected income must originate from your trade or business rather than unrelated personal or investment activities.
   
   
2. The calculation uses three base years for comparison: This rule matters because taxable income from 2016, 2017, and 2018 must be used to recalculate tax using the historical tax brackets assigned to each base year.
   
   
3. Capital losses and net operating losses require careful adjustments. This rule exists because the IRS prohibits including disallowed capital loss amounts or specific net operating loss components in the averaging calculation.
   
   
4. Social Security Number accuracy and eligibility checks are required: This rule helps prevent processing issues because the Internal Revenue Service validates each identifying number for all eligible individuals before accepting the form.
   
   
5. Prior-year amendments may require recalculating your Schedule J figures: This rule is essential because IRS corrections, state penalty adjustments, or changes to prior taxable income could alter the results of your averaging election.

Request an IRS account transcript to confirm your taxable income and adjustments for all Schedule J base years.

 Step-by-Step (High Level)

This section provides a clear overview of the significant steps involved in completing IRS Form 1040 Schedule J (2019).

1. Identify your taxable income from Form 1040 for the 2019 tax year: This step matters because the Schedule J calculation begins with the correct taxable income amount reported on your income tax return.
   
   
2. Calculate the elected farming or fishing income to include: This step requires reviewing Schedule F, Schedule C, Schedule E, Form 4835, and Form 4797 because these forms show gains, losses, and sales related to your trade or business activity.
   
   
3. Compute the non-farm portion of your income: This step requires subtracting the elected farm or fishing income from your total taxable income because the remaining portion uses the current year’s tax rates.
   
   
4. Allocate one-third of the elected income to each base year: This step is necessary because income averaging divides the elected amount equally among the three base years to analyze how older tax brackets affect your tax liability.
   
   
5. Refigure the tax for each base year using historical forms and tax rates. This step may require referencing Schedule D instructions, Form 8949, Form 4952, Form 8814, Schedule A, and the Foreign Earned Income Tax Worksheet, as the recalculation must match IRS rules for those years.
   
   
6. Compare the averaged calculation with the standard 2019 tax calculation: This step determines whether income averaging lowers your overall tax liability because the Internal Revenue Service permits the election only if it results in a reduced tax.
   
   
7. Prepare supporting documents or bookkeeping service records for verification: This step helps maintain accurate figures because income from Form 1099-K, business deductions, and financial records must align with the IRS requirements.

Common Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

This section highlights frequent errors taxpayers make and how to correct them before filing.

1. Missing prior-year taxable income information: To avoid this, request transcripts using Form 4506 so that your base-year figures match IRS records and prevent discrepancies during review.
   
   
2. Including ineligible income in the averaging calculation: To avoid this, confirm that all elected amounts come directly from eligible farming or fishing activities because unrelated income is not permitted on Schedule J.
   
   
3. Incorrect handling of capital loss or net operating loss adjustments: To avoid this, review the Instructions for Schedule J and prior-year worksheets so your capital loss or net operating loss amounts comply with IRS limitations.
   
   
4. Forgetting filing deadlines or extension rules: To avoid this, track your deadlines carefully or use Form 4868 because late elections cannot be made once the filing and amendment periods have expired.
   
   
5. Not saving supporting documents for possible IRS review: To avoid this, keep organized financial records because the IRS may request proof through a Tax Audit or audit letter.

What Happens After You File

Once you file IRS Form 1040 Schedule J (2019), the Internal Revenue Service processes the election as part of your overall income tax return. It recalculates your final tax liability based on the averaging method. If the averaged calculation is accurate, your adjusted tax burden becomes the amount reflected on your return. 

FAQs

Can IRS Form 1040 Schedule J be used if farming income is reported on both Schedule F and Form 4835?

Yes, income averaging can be used when income is reported on both Schedule F and Form 4835, because the Internal Revenue Service requires all income from the trade or business of farming to be combined for calculation purposes.

Does income averaging affect the alternative minimum tax calculated on Form 6251?

No, income averaging does not affect the alternative minimum tax because Form 6251 uses separate rules that are not influenced by Schedule J calculations.

Can an amended return include a corrected Schedule J after filing?

Yes, an amended return can include a corrected Schedule J when filed on Form 1040-X because the Internal Revenue Service allows changes within the standard amendment window.

What happens if a Social Security Number is incorrect on a Schedule J submission?

An incorrect Social Security Number may delay processing because the Internal Revenue Service must verify identifying information before adjusting tax liability.